Government Technology

    Digital Communities
    Industry Members

  • Click sponsor logos for whitepapers, case studies, and best practices.
  • AT&T Logo
  • McAfee
  • Net App

How Voting Equipment Varies in the U.S.

Photo courtesy of Ho John Lee (Flickr CC)

October 24, 2011 By

Pamela Smith and the Verified Voting Foundation (VVF) are on a mission — in her words — "to safeguard elections in the digital age."

In an earlier time, she said, ballot boxes were inspected the morning before voting began then were padlocked. Voters would insert their paper ballots, and when the polls closed, officials would unlock the boxes and count the ballots. Smith, the foundation’s president, isn't advocating a return to those simpler days, but she says that some modern electronic voting systems present unique challenges that make democracy vulnerable to tampering.

With some systems, said Smith, the voter marks a paper ballot, which then goes through an electronic scanner for tallying the vote. With that kind of system, she said, there's a hard-copy record of the vote that can be used to audit accuracy, or in the event of a recount.

The foundation's map of "America's Voting Systems in 2010" show a broad range of systems, from Oregon's vote-by-mail to South Carolina's "DRE without VVPAT," which signifies a direct recording electronic voting machine that has no voter-verified paper audit trail.

The liabilities of DRE without VVPAT were illustrated in the Washington state gubernatorial election of 2004, said Smith. "At that time there were some large jurisdictions using electronic voting machines that didn't have a paper record of any kind,” she said. “They did a statewide recount of a million paper ballots — but they couldn't recount the DRE ballots, so there was no way to tell if those were accurate."

How close was election? Christine Gregoire was elected governor by 133 votes. But because of the DRE component, said Smith, no one could be certain that was the accurate margin of victory.

Voters want confidence and certainty in the results. "They don't want to be told: 'Just trust us,'" Smith said.

South Carolina is one of six states marked on the foundation's map as using DRE without VVPAT, and Smith said there have been election anomalies and unexpected results that people found unusual. "But there was no way to authenticate it," she said. "There have been forensic examinations of some of the data and they've found problems with the electronic audit logs inside the voting machines."

Other states are making modifications to electronic voting systems. New Jersey passed a paper trail requirement back in 2005 scheduled for 2008 implementation, but it has been on hold because of the state’s budget. Maryland is following a similar track. Florida also changed to a paper backup system, with the exception that it’s using some DREs for those with disabilities.

Many jurisdictions enable independent voting for those with impaired vision or other disabilities by using electronic voting systems that feature auditory technology and similar assistance tools. Smith said that these "accessible ballot marking devices" also have the benefit of providing a paper backup. They use an interface that is similar to a DRE, she said, like a touchscreen voting machine with an audio interface. But instead of recording the vote electronically, it prints the vote onto a paper ballot, and that ballot can be reinserted into the ballot marking device and read back to the voter so that they can be sure it actually captured what they marked. Smith said Florida is moving to that type of system.

Vote by mail — a paper-based system — would seem to have few inherent disadvantages at first blush. Some states allow absentee voting that way, and Oregon has moved completely to vote-by-mail. While Smith said Oregon seems happy with it, it may not be successful for all jurisdictions. "Remote voting" ballots travel in the mail with no tracking or monitoring. And while Oregonians may trust the Postal Service, at least one bill in Congress aims to put Fed-X style tracking on vote-by-mail ballots.

Coercion and privacy are also considerations. People voting at a polling station, said Smith, "don't have anybody looking over their shoulder telling them how to vote, ‘or else.’" And voting from home can be susceptible to payment in exchange for votes. The big advantage of vote-by-mail is that it costs less, said Smith.

The Verified Voter Foundation is working on a report called "Is America Ready to Vote" that will update its 2008 report and give the latest data on voting system usage, criteria and more. It’s about democracy, said Smith. "If we don't like somebody or something, we can vote them out. But if you can't rely on the accuracy or reliability of the vote count, then you've got a problem. So our job is safeguarding democracy and getting us past that vulnerability."

| More


gil mayers    |    Commented November 23, 2011
the very least we should have is a consistent- verifiable voting machine with a paper receipt that we as voters can verify at the voting booth and that can be dropped into a separate audit container for recounts and election results. We do not need a Diebold machine with proprietary codes when we pay them. Transparency is a must as this is the few times we as voters are represented and can voice our choice.

Add Your Comment

You are solely responsible for the content of your comments. We reserve the right to remove comments that are considered profane, vulgar, obscene, factually inaccurate, off-topic, or considered a personal attack.

In Our Library

White Papers | Exclusives Reports | Webinar Archives | Best Practices and Case Studies
Using Wireless Technology to Manage and Optimize Government Fleets: Saving Money, Generating Revenues, and Increasing Safety
Using Wireless Technology to Manage and Optimize Government Fleets: Saving Money, Generating Revenues, and Increasing Safety. The paper discusses the challenges federal, state and local government agencies currently face with their government fleets; how mobile technology can help; considerations when selecting a mobile solutions partner; and the benefits of choosing Sprint. Specifically, Frost & Sullivan highlights Sprint’s fleet expertise, its powerful networks, and advanced partnerships that work in concert to provide government fleets with the ability to: Save money, Generate new revenues, Enhance safety, Help the environment, Increase the availability and transparency of information to the public
The New Reality of Stealth Crimeware White Paper
Take the stealth, creativity, and patience of Stuxnet. Add the commercialism, wide distribution, and easy-to-use tool kits of Zeus. Consider that despite more than years of activity, as of May 2011, neither of these cyber criminal teams has been exposed. You now understand the recipe—and potency—of today’s malware. Start planning now. It will take more than signatures and operating system-level protections to protect your intellectual property and other assets against criminals wielding these weapons.
Minimize Lifetime Costs of Govt Networks
Public sector organizations are preparing to upgrade their transport networks to accommodate a surge in traffic from business video and network-based backups.
View All

Digital Communities members get access to our collaboration task forces

427 Members

77 Discussions

84 Files

Latest members Become a member

Digital Communities members get access to our collaboration task forces

669 Members

145 Discussions

150 Files

Latest members Become a member


Featured White Papers & Reports

CIOs Redefine Local Government and Industry Relations

Based off of discussions of the Digital Communities Large Jurisdiction Chief Information Officer (CIO) Working Group, this white paper aims to answer the question, "In today's economic, political and business environment, what constitutes a successful relationship between government and industry?" Cause for Optimism identifies and clarifies the issues that separate government and industry, and begins to find an answer to the question necessary for both to enjoy a successful and prosperous future.

View Full Library


GTC East

Don't miss this opportunity to see the latest in digital government solutions, keep abreast of current policy issues and network with key government executives, technologists and industry specialists.

View All Events